MakeMyTrip Share Price Decline Analysis: Factors and Fair Value Model Reliability

Based on my comprehensive analysis, here is a detailed examination of MakeMyTrip’s share price decline and the reliability of fair value models in predicting overvalued stocks in the travel technology sector.

---

MakeMyTrip Limited (NASDAQ: MMYT), India’s leading online travel aggregator, experienced a dramatic

in its share price from February 2025 to January 2026. This decline was notably predicted by InvestingPro’s Fair Value model, which identified the stock as significantly overvalued at $116.69, estimating a fair value of $69.54—implying a potential downside of 40.41% [1][2]. The actual decline to $62.59 exceeded this forecast, validating the model’s predictive capability while also highlighting the inherent challenges in precisely timing market movements.

---

The primary factor driving MakeMyTrip’s share price decline was a severe disconnect between market price and intrinsic value. At its February 2025 peak of $116.69, the stock was trading at extraordinary multiples [1][2]:

Valuation Metric	MakeMyTrip	Industry Average
P/E Ratio	107.77x	~21x
P/B Ratio	-21.56x	N/A
EV/OCF	32.18x	Variable

The InvestingPro model estimated the fair value at

, suggesting the stock was overvalued by approximately 40% before the decline began [1]. This assessment was based on a comprehensive multi-factor analysis that identified a significant gap between market expectations and underlying business fundamentals.

The most immediate trigger for the recent decline was the

on January 21, 2026 [3]:

• Revenue
  : $295.69 million vs. analyst consensus of $306.29 million (-3.46% miss)
• EPS
  : $0.52 actual vs. $0.39 estimate (+33.33% surprise)

Despite beating earnings per share expectations, the revenue shortfall prompted an 8% single-day decline [3]. Management cited

, primarily driven by that limited flight capacity in India, as the primary reason for the revenue underperformance [3].

A critical concern for investors was the sharp deterioration in profitability metrics [1][2]:

• EPS fell sharply from
  $2.12 to $0.54
  despite revenue growth
• Operating margin compression signals weakening cost discipline
• The company maintains aggressive accounting practices with low depreciation/capex ratios

The decline in earnings despite top-line growth indicated deteriorating margins and raised questions about the company’s path to sustainable profitability [1][2].

In 2025, several major investment banks, including

, lowered their price targets citing “air supply issues and flight disruptions” [1]. These downgrades reflected growing concerns about:

• Weakening travel demand trends
• Platform scaling concerns
• Broader negative sentiment toward tech-enabled consumer services
• Flight supply constraints impacting revenue generation [2]

Ongoing geopolitical tensions and operational disruptions created additional headwinds [1]:

• Political tensions affecting international travel demand
• Increased operating costs from supply chain disruptions
• Uncertainty surrounding regulatory changes in India’s aviation sector

---

InvestingPro’s Fair Value model demonstrated

in predicting MakeMyTrip’s decline [1][4]:

Metric	Prediction	Actual Outcome
Fair Value Estimate	$69.54	Current Price: $62.59
Predicted Downside	40.41%	46.36% decline
Timing	October 2025 flag	Decline realized by January 2026

The model successfully identified the stock as overvalued

the major decline occurred, providing investors with an early warning signal [1][4]. This aligns with the model’s prior success in predicting Atai Life Sciences’ 35% decline, where the model estimated fair value at $4.22 against a market price of $6.45 [4].

InvestingPro employs a sophisticated multi-method approach [4][5]:

1. Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)
   : Projects future free cash flows and discounts to present value using company-specific WACC
2. Comparable Company Analysis
   : Applies industry multiples (P/E, EV/EBITDA, EV/FCF) from peer groups
3. Market-Range Analysis
   : Evaluates historical price volatility to identify abnormal trading bands

• Multi-method aggregation
  combining DCF, relative valuation, and market analysis
• Sector-specific tuning
  adjusting for industry dynamics unique to travel technology
• Quantitative rigor
  with proprietary algorithms weighting each method according to financial profile
• Continuous refinement
  with automatic updates from new earnings and market data [4]

However, significant discrepancies exist between different fair value methodologies [6]:

Model	Fair Value Estimate	Upside/Downside
InvestingPro Fair Value	$69.54	-40.41% downside
DCF Base Case	$8.60	-86.3% downside
DCF Optimistic	$8.80	-85.9% downside
Simply Wall St DCF	~$17.50	~72% overvalued

This divergence highlights a fundamental challenge:

, and for high-growth, pre-profit companies like MakeMyTrip, small changes in assumptions produce dramatically different valuations [6].

1. High Growth Expectations
   : Travel technology companies often trade on growth narratives rather than current earnings, making traditional metrics less reliable [2]
2. Cyclical Demand
   : Travel demand is sensitive to economic conditions, geopolitical factors, and seasonal patterns
3. Regulatory Uncertainty
   : Aviation regulations (like FDTL restrictions) can significantly impact operational capacity
4. Competitive Dynamics
   : The online travel agency space is highly competitive with changing market share dynamics [2]

• Cannot predict
  timing
  of price corrections, only direction
• Sensitivity to input assumptions in DCF models
• May undervalue strategic positioning or intangible assets
• Market sentiment can override fundamentals for extended periods [4][5]

---

The travel technology sector presents unique challenges for fair value modeling [2]:

Characteristic	Impact on Valuation
High customer acquisition costs	Pressures short-term margins
Network effects	Potential for winner-take-all dynamics
Platform scaling potential	Justifies premium valuations during growth phases
Regulatory sensitivity	Creates unpredictable headwinds

MakeMyTrip’s valuation metrics significantly exceeded industry averages [2]:

• P/E Ratio
  : 107.77x vs. industry average of ~21x
• Growth premium
  : Market priced in expectations that proved unsustainable
• Operating margins
  : 14.14% operating margin indicates improvement but remains below sector leaders

---

1. Fair Value Models Demonstrated Value
   : InvestingPro’s multi-factor model successfully identified MakeMyTrip as overvalued before the 46% decline, validating the approach [1][4]

2. Multiple Factors Converged
   : The decline resulted from a combination of valuation reversion, operational challenges, and shifting market sentiment toward growth stocks [1][2][3]

3. Model Limitations Persist
   : Despite accurate directional predictions, precise timing and magnitude remain challenging, as evidenced by the DCF model’s even more bearish outlook [6]

4. Sector Complexity
   : Travel technology’s growth-dependent valuation dynamics require sophisticated, multi-model approaches rather than single-metric analysis [2][4]

Aspect	Reliability Rating	Notes
Directional Prediction	High	Successfully identified overvaluation
Magnitude Prediction	Moderate	Underestimated actual decline
Timing Prediction	Low	Cannot predict market sentiment shifts
Sector Applicability	High	Multi-method approach suits complex dynamics

1. Use Fair Value Models as Screening Tools
   : Identify potential overvaluation candidates for further research
2. Combine Multiple Models
   : Cross-reference DCF, relative valuation, and market-range analysis
3. Monitor Operational Fundamentals
   : Revenue misses and margin compression often precede price corrections
4. Consider Sector Dynamics
   : Travel technology requires understanding of both macro trends and company-specific factors

---

MakeMyTrip’s 46% share price decline illustrates the convergence of fundamental overvaluation, operational challenges, and shifting market sentiment in the travel technology sector. InvestingPro’s Fair Value model demonstrated significant predictive value by identifying the overvaluation before the decline materialized, though the actual magnitude exceeded initial projections.

Fair value models prove most reliable when employing

that account for sector-specific dynamics. While no model can perfectly predict market timing, these tools provide valuable early warning signals for investors seeking to avoid overvalued positions. The key insight is that fair value models should be used as within a broader investment framework, not as standalone decision mechanisms.

---

[1] Investing.com - MakeMyTrip shares drop 46% as predicted by InvestingPro’s Fair Value model

[2] Yahoo Finance - Is It Time To Rethink MakeMyTrip (MMYT) After The Recent Share Price Decline?

[3] Alpha Street - MakeMyTrip Shares Fall 8% Following Revenue Miss In Fiscal Third Quarter

[4] Investing.com - InvestingPro’s fair value model accurately predicted Atai’s 35% decline

[5] Investing Support - InvestingPro’s Fair Value

[6] 金灵API数据 - DCF Valuation and Financial Analysis for MMYT